Is it longifolium hincksianum?

Slippertalk Orchid Forum

Help Support Slippertalk Orchid Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
G

goldenrose

Guest
I posted this in my frag fever thread, some may have missed it. It's time for Jean-Pierre's suggestion because now I'm confused!
Read on & add your 2 cents worth!
longifolium001.jpg
longifolium006.jpg



Question/quiz - on a sales table I saw a miniature version of this, flower wise. The foliage was almost grassy, like ecaudorense & only about 6" tall. It was labeled hincksianum but seeing this was the same vendor I got the Cardinale from that was labeled Schroderae, NO WAY! Any idea what it might have been? It was cute as could be!
 
Yes, I saw it in bloom. The plant size was about 6" tall, the flower size was maybe 3'" across with it's outstretched petals. The color of the flower had more red like mine does but shape wise it's like both of ours.
I guess the first question is what is the difference between a regular longifolium & the hincksianum variety? I'm under the impression, the richer color? Second question - how can this little mini version, having a different plant habit, be called a hincksianum too?
 
hincksianum is a dwarf variety according to my limited knowledge. I have a Eric Young using hincksianum, and she said it is the compact lonigolium
 
Not all longifolium are hincksianum

ALL hincksianum are longifolium
.

Phrag hincksianum is a geographic race of the wide spread species longifolium. (think hincksianum is a subset or subspecies)

Phrag longifolium includes the wide leaved forms from Colombia & Venezuela that can have flowers stems 5 feet tall down to the little Ecuadorian races with narrow sedge shaped leaves and total less than 12 inches tall. Hincksianum is the Panama race of longifolium with narrow sedge shape leaves and is about 24 inches tall.

My taxonomic recollection has not been updated to the 21st century - I have not read much taxonomy the last 5 years so my info is a little out of date. I believe there is an article out there citing why hincksianum is not a valid name, also gracile, and proposing the correct names, with a clearer definition of what constitutes what - but I have not read it yet - so I don't know the latest. But the name hincksianum was in common use when I was reading the literature - so my comments reflect the way the name has been used through to 2001.

What is really key - these names are tied to geographic regions of origin. If you have a plant, and you don't know where it came from, you may NEVER be able to say with certainty what the plant is beyond calling it longifolium. The small forms of Phrag longifolium from Ecuador commonly called the variety gracile are difficult to differentiate from the somewhat taller growing form from Panama - but the vouchered speciemens truely known to be from one location or the other are definitely different subspecies, and clearly not of the same origin. Once they get mixed up in cultivation there is no way to separate them reliably. There is no vouchered DNA referance database that can be used. One would have to go through the expense of going to each country and collecting DNA there in order to create a reliable vouchered DNA database. Unfortunately the money is not available to do this. Unfortunately what people tell you about the origin of any particular plant in cultivation may be suspect - if there were any mis-recollections or mis-statements as the plant changes hands, you can end up holding a mis-labelled plant.

To my eye, your photo and description of a plant whose vegetation is only 6 inches tall more closely suggests the subspecies gracile which is of Ecuadorian origin, rather than the taller hincksianum which is of Panamanian origin.

But a badly grown hicnksianum might be shorter than a well grown gracile. With plants in cultivation it is often impossible to say anything more specific than that's a nice Phrag. or maybe that's a nice Phrag longifolium.
 
I looked at this plant closely as well and think it could be something called Phrag, longifolium var Hartwegii that I once saw blooming in **** Clement's collection back in the day. The leaves on the mystery plant seemed wider than I would expect for a typical "gracile" and a lot shorter, and the flower was smaller than a typical longifolium. I wish someone like Cribb or Olaf would publish a book on this Genus in total. Wouldn't it be great to have something like Cribb's "The Genus Paphiopedilum" covering Phrag. species? Long overdue, IMHO.

Thanks, Tom
 
This taxonomy gets confusing but my dwarf longifolium is labelled as "gracile", and I always thought that hincksianum was big and gracile is small, as Leo said. As to how big hincksianum is compared to regular longifolium, I'm not really sure.
 
small to big

gracile (under 12 inches) - hincksianum - roezlii - longifolium (up to 5 ft tall)

I am not sure where hartwegii fits in, I am not sure I ever saw a real one. I did not see the **** Clements plant in bloom. The plant I had labelled as hartwegii also had a tag saying gracile. Also had plants labelled hirtzii that were clearly longifolium var gracile. Not sure what to think on all that.
 
I want a pot of the little one; did you buy it and who was selling?
I'm glad Tom saw it as well. It was a cute as can be, I was so tempted BUT ....
no I didn't buy it, this was the same vendor at the Madison show that I got the so-called Schroderae from, that turned out to be probably Cardinale, according the forum members here. I felt I already gave him $35 for technically a noID, did I want to do it again?
Fool me once, same on you,
fool me twice, shame on me ....


Thanks for the history lesson, once again Leo!
 
I agree with Tom, that a definitive book on Phrags is long past due. Right now, the best source is phragweb, but it would be good to have a book.
 
I thought gracile was less colorful (less red/pink) too? Hinksianum has been described to me as the most colorful of the longifoliums, but on modest to big plants? I'm certainly not up to speed on my green phrags though.

-Ernie
 

Latest posts

Back
Top