Paphiopedilum Maudiae

[Hakone]

Maudiae or not Maudiae ?

 

[Ozpaph]

i vote no

 

[GuRu]

i vote no

Ozpaph, I second your vote.

 

[Hakone]

closeup

 

[GuRu]

Hakone, even with the closeup I won't change my vote.

 

[Hakone]

Hakone, even with the closeup I won't change my vote.

why ? Maudiae 100% ?

 

[MorandiWine]

Looks like there is some chuck in there...

 

[GuRu]

Flower shape and stance and shape of the leaves......they aren't Maudiae like

why ? Maudiae 100% ?

Hakone, when you think it's 100% Maudiae.....why do you ask for a assessment?

 

[Hakone]

all Paphiopedilum Guru give no answers, you mean lawrenceanum fma hyeanum , 1885.

with Sam´s permission, paphiopedilum lawrenceanum fma hyeanum

 

[Hakone]

or paphiopedilum hennisianum fma christiansenii

Sam ´s plant hennisianum fma christiansenii Green Latern

 

[GuRu]

Baloney, Hakone. You asked for an assessment and others and I said our opinion. The rest is up to you, particularly whether you like these statements or not.

 

[Guldal]

Ozpaph, I second your vote.

So do I! That dorsal simply isn't right - it looks like someone crossed a Maudiae with charlesworthii fma. sanderae (albino form).

This is what a true Maudiae (P. callosum fma. album x P. lawrenceanum fma. hyeanum) looks like - my classic 'Bankhouse' clone:



IMO your flower might more appropriately be designated as 'a Maudiae type hybrid'.

And a finally: what a photo of P. hennissianum fma. christiansenii, albeit a joy to the eyes and named after my friend, Hans Christiansen, do in a thread titled 'Paphiopedilum Maudiae' is unfathomable?!

 

[GuRu]

.........This is how a true Maudiae (P. callosum fma. album x P. lawrenceanum fma. hyeanum) looks like - my classic 'Bankhouse' clone:

View attachment 21847

IMO your flower might more appropriately be designated as 'a Maudiae type hybrid'.............

Jens, you are sooo right.

 

[Hakone]

Guru and Jens , you are having the same opinion with Xavier deloubresse . I'm still waiting for 5 reports

thanks

 

[Hakone]

So do I! That dorsal simply isn't right - it looks like someone crossed a Maudiae with charlesworthii fma. album.

This is how a true Maudiae (P. callosum fma. album x P. lawrenceanum fma. hyeanum) looks like - my classic 'Bankhouse' clone:

View attachment 21847

IMO your flower might more appropriately be designated as 'a Maudiae type hybrid'.

And a final question: what a photo of P. hennissianum fma. christiansenii, albeit a joy to the eyes and named after my friend, Hans Christiansen, do in a thread titled 'Paphiopedilum Maudiae' is unfathomable?!

The leaf marbling differs lawrenceanum from maudie (It would tell me )

 

[blondie]

by the leaf and the flower it looks very similar to my P. Rosettii