I already invested in 5 lb of MSU and 5 of Calcium Nitrate, which is going to last me quite some time...I'll have to sit back and watch the results of you all.
Ups! If read well the thread mentioned and after some computations it is 10% Ca and 4% Mg.Check out the other "K lite" thread....
That's 14.5# minimum, 24.5# max.
I think that, if we're are limited, we should allow participants in this forum to take precedence over others. Is that OK?
Should we really use additives in this first trial? I think one could mask potential problems.
How strict should we be on keeping records? Should we issue a spread sheet?
Better than records is just generally keeping track of what you do and do it on a regular basis or schedule. Use the K-lite fertilizer instead of your regular fertilizer and see what happens. If you all of a sudden notice that your plants look better, then the new fertilizer is effective. If you don't really notice a change then it has not made enough difference for a short test to determine anything.
Probably two ways to look at your first question. Ideally the answer is yes, but since this is a bit more of a Beta test under real life hobby conditions, I wouldn't necessarily expect everyone to give up their personal creative experimenting.
Same for records. It's gotta be convenient or records fall apart. I already put in 40++ hours getting paid for producing data, but despite my personal knowledge and experience of the importance of good record keeping it's just about all I can manage in my hobby time to keep up with this forum (as a form of documentation).
Certainly with plants we are talking months and years rather than hours and days, so you would think it wouldn't kill me (or anyone else trying this) to use a log book and keep notes, but I'm sure I'll be the first one to slob out on this, and go by memory and intuition.
Better than records is just generally keeping track of what you do and do it on a regular basis or schedule. Use the K-lite fertilizer instead of your regular fertilizer and see what happens. If you all of a sudden notice that your plants look better, then the new fertilizer is effective. If you don't really notice a change then it has not made enough difference for a short test to determine anything.
Isn't the point of this "experiment" to see how this fertilizer works? Hows one going to know the real results if one is adding kelp, rooting hormones, or what ever else one uses?
Agreed but records are important for others and yourself..... I guess weekly up date on a thread may work.
This is why people involved need a year supply
So far, this is what I've got:
Rick - 2 or 5
Ray - 2 or 4
Ross - 2
Eric M - 2 jar
yakmanq - 2 jar
jtrmd - 2 or 3
Jim T - 2 or 6
cnycharles - 0.5
That's 14.5# minimum, 24.5# max.
I think that, if we're are limited, we should allow participants in this forum to take precedence over others. Is that OK?
Isn't that part of recording records?
I thought we where testing both?!?!?!The major point is to see how the low potassium levels effect growth. So ideally you would just substitute this formula for your base formula that you have been using. Continue to add your extras. The results you see will be because of the low potassium level.
TrueRecords are good but.... Even without records you will have an opinion whether or not you see an improvement of growth or less disease problems. That overall opinion everyone forms is the result, regardless of what is in recorded records.
I think Rick said he noticed "results" in a few months time? Rick?
A possible obstacle to seeing results is that your media that is in the pots already may me overdosed with potassium already. That may slow down the quickness of seeing any results.
I thought we where testing both?!?!?!
He said in a few post back that it would take months and years. You may see result in a few months but you also need to see results a year from now.
Yes -- I just went through the whole thread and found this:...
Dot, I posted Bill's complete formula proposal - I think in the original K-Lite thread.
Enter your email address to join: