Lady Isabel or Lady Rothschild

[Barry]

I bought this as Lady Rothschild seedlings but it looks like a Lady Isabel!

 

[Shiva]

Lady Isabel is roth x stonei while Lady Rotschild is roth x Lady Isabel.

Maybe this LR came out closer to the LI parent. So I would keep the name Lady Rothschild. Very nice roth hybrid by the way. :clap:

 

[NYEric]

Hideous! Send it to me.

 

[nikv]

I'm seeing four flowers on a spike. And the flowers are pretty. I think the tag is correct, just that it favors the Lady Isabel parent.

 

[emydura]

It doesn't quite look right for Lady Isabel to me. Lady Rothschild looks a better fit.

 

[Justin]

i think it is Lady Rothschild. will be better next flowering i'm sure.

 

[SlipperFan]

It's a beautiful lady, whichever one it is.

 

[ehanes7612]

it could be either one...there is no way to tell..when you start getting into complexes , especially breeding back unto the parents..you can have plants that can have a wide range of expression from one parent to another ...i have seen this with Monsoon temptation, PEOY x SAnders Pride, as well as sandy crosses crossed back with sanderianum...basically, the seedlings that this pod came from could have a many plants that look like Lady Roth and Lady Isabel,

 

[emydura]

it could be either one...there is no way to tell..when you start getting into complexes , especially breeding back unto the parents..you can have plants that can have a wide range of expression from one parent to another ...i have seen this with Monsoon temptation, PEOY x SAnders Pride, as well as sandy crosses crossed back with sanderianum...basically, the seedlings that this pod came from could have a many plants that look like Lady Roth and Lady Isabel,

True. But I have never seen a Lady Isabel that looked like that. But I have seen a couple of Lady Rothschild's which looked similar. Although I have seen Lady Rothschild's that looked totally different. The variation of complex hybrids as you say. If the label says Lady Rothschild than I see no reason to doubt it.

 

[Fabrice]

I agree. I can't be categorical but for me, it's a Lady Roth. Nice one with lots of white/yellow color. I like it!

 

[SlipperKing]

I would believe the tag too.

 

[ehanes7612]

True. But I have never seen a Lady Isabel that looked like that. But I have seen a couple of Lady Rothschild's which looked similar. Although I have seen Lady Rothschild's that looked totally different. The variation of complex hybrids as you say. If the label says Lady Rothschild than I see no reason to doubt it.

weel..yeah..i would go with the label,,because there is no way to make an educated guess

 

[W. Beetus]

Quite a nice bloom! I definitely see roth in the bloom, so I would call it Lady Rothschild.

 

[Barry]

Thank you all of your help!