I did try the caffine solution some 6 years ago. At the time I could get lab reagent grade caffine. (alas, no longer true). The article I used to based my dose rate on is on the work computer that I no longer have access to. I believe it was a 0.5% solution. It took me 15 gallons of spray to completely wet the foliage and drench all the pots in my collection once. I went through 500 grams of caffine, at a cost of about $125 for one 500 gram bottle of caffine. The treatment of a 1000 plant collection seemed to work, excellent results for a one time application. But because of the cost I did not follow up with repeat applications. The slugs came back after a while. I did get an unsightly residue on the leaves. It washed off in time. Unless I get a better suggestion, I think I will stick to metaldehyde and / or the iron phosphate.